Key takeaways
- There is no neutral ranking of the best GEO agency. Most "top agency" lists are published by agencies that rank themselves.
- A good GEO agency shows its method in writing: which questions it tests, in which AIs, how often, and what it changes every month.
- Walk away from guaranteed AI mentions, "AI rank position" reports and llms.txt sold as the main fix.
- Ask for real reports from Search Console and Bing, not only screenshots from a private tool.
Is there a best GEO agency?
No single best GEO agency exists for everyone, and no independent body ranks them. The best GEO agency for you is the one that tests the questions your buyers ask, explains its method in writing, reports real data, works white-hat and fits your budget. Use the criteria below to compare the two or three you are considering.
The question "who is the best GEO agency" deserves a straight answer: it depends on your market, language and budget, and anyone who claims a universal ranking is selling. GEO is young. The Google guide to generative AI features was updated in July 2026 and Search Console's AI report only reached all sites in August 2026, so nobody has a long track record yet. Judge agencies by method and honesty. If you are hiring for classic SEO, my guide on how to choose an SEO consultant covers that side; the GEO hub explains the discipline itself.
What should a GEO agency actually deliver?
A GEO agency should deliver four things you can check: a baseline test of your buyer questions in several AI assistants, a list of the errors found and fixed, new or rewritten content and outside mentions, and monthly reports that include Search Console and Bing AI data. If you cannot see the work, you cannot judge it.
| Deliverable | What good looks like | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| Baseline AI test | A fixed list of buyer questions, run in named AIs and languages, repeated on a schedule | One screenshot of one answer |
| Technical fixes | AI crawler access checked in robots.txt and CDN, indexing, schema, page speed | "We optimized your site for AI" with no list |
| Content | Pages rewritten to answer questions with facts and sources | Dozens of thin AI-written posts |
| Outside proof | Real reviews, industry lists, press and forum mentions earned in the open | Bought links, fake reviews, paid "AI citations" |
| Reporting | Search Console AI impressions, Bing AI citations, mention rate across repeated tests | A private "AI score" you cannot verify |
What questions should you ask before hiring a GEO agency?
Ask which buyer questions they will test and in which AIs, how many times each test runs, what they change in month one, how they report results, who does the work, and how you can leave. Google's own list of questions for hiring an SEO applies too: past work, methods, timelines and how they measure success.
- Which questions, which AIs, which languages? You should approve the list. For Latin American businesses, insist on Spanish tests.
- How often is each question repeated? AI answers change between runs, so one run proves nothing.
- What exactly happens in month one? Ask for the deliverables in writing.
- Do you follow Google Search Essentials? It is one of the questions in Google's guide to hiring an SEO.
- Can I see a sample report? It should include Search Console and Bing data, not only screenshots.
- Who does the work? The person you meet in sales, or a team you never talk to?
- What stays mine if I leave? Audit, content, accounts and data should be yours.
What are the GEO agency red flags?
The main GEO agency red flags are guaranteed mentions in ChatGPT or Google's AI, reports built on an "AI rank position", llms.txt or schema sold as the main fix, fake reviews or bought citations, and secrecy about what they do. Any one of them is a reason to keep looking, whatever the price.
- Guaranteed AI rankings. Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking, and if someone does, you should find someone else. The same applies to AI answers, which no agency controls.
- Fake "AI rank" metrics. In a SparkToro study, ChatGPT and Google's AI repeated the same list of brands in under 1 in 100 answers to the same prompt, and the same order about once in 1,000. Mention rate across many runs is meaningful; a single "position" is not.
- llms.txt as magic. Google says its AI features do not need AI text files, and John Mueller said no AI service has said it uses llms.txt. It is a small optional file, not a strategy.
- Fake reviews or paid mentions. The FTC's rule bans fake reviews, including AI-generated ones. An agency that offers them puts your business at risk.
- Secrecy. "Proprietary method" with no explanation of what changes on your site is a warning, not a feature.
- Cold outreach with alarms. Google also warns about firms that email you out of the blue.
How much should a GEO agency cost?
Prices vary a lot, so ask for them in writing and compare what each month includes, not only the total. A fair offer separates a one-time diagnosis from the monthly work, says how many pages and articles are included, and lets you cancel. Be careful with low prices that only buy a monitoring dashboard.
As a reference, these are my published prices: a GEO audit from USD 400 one time, then monthly GEO plans of USD 1,750 (Growth) and USD 2,500 (Scale), with every deliverable listed on the GEO services page. I publish them so you can compare. Whoever you hire, use the AI share of voice guide to check their reports, and the home page if you want to know how I work.
Frequently asked questions
Is GEO different from SEO for hiring purposes?
GEO builds on SEO, so a good GEO agency must know SEO. The difference is that it also tests and reports what AI assistants say about you. Ask for examples of those reports before hiring, and who will run the tests.
Should I hire an agency or a freelancer for GEO?
Either can work. What matters is who does the work, the method in writing and the reports, not the size of the company. Ask for a sample monthly report and who will run the tests each month. Compare offers on the same terms.
How long should a GEO contract last?
Prefer month-to-month terms or a short first period. AI answers change quickly, and you should be able to leave if the work is not visible. Check which deliverables you get each month before signing, and how to cancel. Ask about the notice period too.
Can a GEO agency get me into ChatGPT in a week?
Fixes to crawl access and pages can show in live AI searches within weeks, but no agency can promise a mention, let alone a date. Ask for a plan with tasks and dates, and measure progress with the same questions every month.
What tools should a GEO agency use?
Free official reports first: Search Console, Bing Webmaster Tools and GA4. Paid tracking tools are optional and should explain their method. If it uses a paid tool, ask how it measures and in which countries and languages. Prefer tools that show cited sources.
Want to see these guides first? Choose JJ SEO Colombia as a preferred source on Google, and my articles are more likely to show up for you in Top Stories.
Follow on GoogleAdd as a preferred sourceSources
- Google Search Central, Do you need an SEO?
- SparkToro, AIs are highly inconsistent when recommending brands or products (Rand Fishkin, January 27, 2026)
- Google Search Central, Google's Guide to Optimizing for Generative AI Features on Google Search (updated July 10, 2026)
- Search Engine Journal, Google Says LLMs.Txt Comparable To Keywords Meta Tag (April 17, 2025)
- Federal Trade Commission, Final rule banning fake reviews and testimonials (August 14, 2024)
- Search Console Help, Generative AI performance report (Search)
- Bing Webmaster Blog, Introducing AI Performance in Bing Webmaster Tools public preview (February 10, 2026)